This is the first part of three in our series on growing public distrust in non-profits.
It’s an uncomfortable question: Are nonprofits more focused on their own needs than the communities they’re supposed to help?
For many of us non-profit warriors it is easy to get our back up a wall when this question arises. We have after all spent years in the trenches, working in and with organizations, sometimes donating our time, sweat and tears to advance organizational mission. We hear a question like this and feel threatened. When we feel threatened, we either attack or retreat.
The hard truth, like many things, is a mix of both external and internal influences that have brought us to this point.
In this week’s post, I’d like to consider some of the external influences that are challenging the work nonprofits do and contributing to the loss of reputation.
So, how did we get here? How did nonprofits go from being do-gooders to self-serving entities in the eyes of the public?
Political Polarization and Nonprofit Advocacy: In today’s divided political climate, nonprofits are often perceived as aligning with certain political agendas, leading to a growing mistrust. Nonprofits advocating for social justice, environmental issues, or public health can be seen as politically motivated, making people question their impartiality and true mission. This political polarization has fueled doubts about nonprofit transparency and effectiveness. Does this mean non-profits should not be political? Not at all, but unfortunately, it does make people align and choose sides.
The Erosion of Trust in Institutions: Across various sectors, there’s a general erosion of trust in traditional institutions, including nonprofits. Scandals in both government and business, combined with broader societal issues, have led people to view large organizations with suspicion, including nonprofits. One of the single biggest erosions, has been that of religion. As our religious institutions are seen as increasingly fallible, by association it corrupts the organizations that were associated in the same ecosystem. When there’s a constant barrage of negative stories about corruption, mismanagement, or unethical behavior, it can create a generalized distrust that spills over to the nonprofit sector. As people become more cynical about institutions in general, they begin questioning whether nonprofits are really any different, even if their mission is rooted in social good.
Widespread Distrust in the Media: As skepticism toward the media increases, many people are questioning the reliability of news, especially when it comes to reporting on nonprofits. Sensationalized headlines, misleading stories, or the lack of context can distort the public’s understanding of nonprofit organizations. When negative coverage, even if isolated or exaggerated, is amplified by the media, it can feed into a broader perception that nonprofits are not as trustworthy as they claim to be. This media environment fuels doubt and complicates efforts to build trust in the nonprofit sector.
Corporate Influence and Partnerships: As nonprofits increasingly partner with large corporations or receive funding from for-profit entities, there’s growing concern that they are becoming too corporate in their approach. This shift can create the perception that nonprofits are more focused on aligning with business interests or boosting their own influence, rather than staying true to their mission. These corporate ties may make nonprofits appear more self-serving and less focused on social impact, leading to a rise in distrust among the public.
Donor Fatigue and Social Media Saturation: With the rise of social media, there’s an overwhelming amount of discourse about societal problems and causes, often with fewer solutions being presented. This constant focus on problems, rather than a language of solutions, leads to overwhelm and fatigue. As organizations of all sizes adopt more professional fundraising, the asks continue to be greater, particularly for higher value donors. A discourse of constant negativity, amplified by the ever-presence of social media, numbs our common consciousness about the problems that exist in our nations, communities and our own backyards.
“A discourse of constant negativity, amplified by the ever-presence of social media, numbs our common consciousness about the problems that exist in our nations, communities and our own backyards”.
There are scores more of factors contributing to this. The issue is not a simple one, but one that will continue to challenge the sector over the coming decades.
Next week we will look at the internal factors that contribute to eroding nonprofit distrust. The following week we will look at solutions.
Like what you’re reading?
Never miss an issue. Sign up for our Non-Profit Nerd Newsletter delivered straight to your inbox each week
Get Our Weekly Articles Delivered Straight to Your Inbox
Honest Conversations About the State of the Non-Profit Sector Today
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.